Neutrogena's Healthy Volume Mascara in Carbon Black impressed me with its intense pigmentation and smooth application. The formula adds impressive volume and length without clumping, and it stays put all day without smudging. I love that it's infused with olive oil for lash nourishment and that it's easy to remove. Overall, this mascara delivers on its promises and has earned a permanent spot in my makeup routine.
The mascara was nice. It went on thick, but the 2 sided wand was helpful to separate and lift my lashes. I don't think it's waterproof, which is my preference. Overall a descent mascara.
Home Tested with free product
1
Brittany(Colorado Springs)
Home Tester Ace
54 Reviews
+1
Brittany(Colorado Springs)
Home Tester Ace
54 Reviews
0 Upload
+1
20/03/2024
Lasting!
This mascara truly lasts all day. I apply this in the morning and my lashes stay in place. The dual bristle brush is very interesting and helps a bit to separate lashes. I find it's best to follow the mascara with a metal lash brush for additional separation.
I really like this mascara. The brush is great at separating my lashes especially with the two different brush options. It makes it so that my eyelashes get evenly coated. The mascara seems to form a tube around my lashes but comes off easily with a makeup remover wipe.
Home Tested with free product
1
Shaunda(Honaker)
Home Tester
5 Reviews
Shaunda(Honaker)
Home Tester
5 Reviews
0 Upload
20/03/2024
Amazing Mascara
I really love this Neutrogena Healthy Definition Mascara. The mascara comes out smooth every time and is never clumpy. I love how easy this mascara is to apply on my eyelashes and the mascara stays and looks great for hours! This mascara is a must have in my daily makeup routine.
Home Tested with free product
0
Camille(Plano)
Home Tester
3 Reviews
Camille(Plano)
Home Tester
3 Reviews
0 Upload
20/03/2024
Was flaky and disappointing
The mascara promised no flaking and unfortunately did the opposite. I loveee Neutrogena so I was sad to be disappointed. The formula was flaky and came off easy. Would not recommend sadly.
In my opinion I think this mascara is amazing. Love how it has two different sides of bristles. The long side bristle is amazing, it did exactly what it says. It really separated my lashes. I actually thought that it wasn't going to work. Love how it made my lashes look long and super black.
I tried it on and felt in love! Love how it makes my lashes longer and not crumpled up together. It also gives a very natural look. Also definitely recommend for sensitive eyes, my eyes didn’t get red or feel uncomfortable at all. My new favorite mascara!
Home Tested with free product
0
Nicole(Churchville)
Home Tester Pro
100 Reviews
Nicole(Churchville)
Home Tester Pro
100 Reviews
0 Upload
19/03/2024
Nice mascara!
I really like this neutrogena mascara! It looks great on my lashes!
I like this product! I like that it’s paraben free and that it has a dual-sided comb. It makes my lashes look long and full. It would be nice if it was waterproof. I would recommend trying this product.
LOVE this mascara it doesn’t clump, doesn’t leave raccoon eyes and it glides on so easily! One thing I do b not like is that it’s not cruelty free. Not sure why we still need to test on animals in this day and age.
Home Tested with free product
0
Maria(Weatherford)
Home Tester Ace
54 Reviews
Maria(Weatherford)
Home Tester Ace
54 Reviews
0 Upload
19/03/2024
Mascara
I was hoping these would be my go to mascara.
The design is great but it did feel a little heavy on my lashes and it did clump a bit. I tried to separate with a spill but it wasn’t as successful, maybe I didn’t apply it correctly. I will
Try again and update the review.
It definitely separates and lengthens my lashes but doesn’t add a lot of volume. It is easy to remove and it doesn’t bother my sensitive eyes. All in all, I can see myself using it daily.
Home Tested with free product
0
Rebecca(Silsbee)
Home Tester
20 Reviews
Rebecca(Silsbee)
Home Tester
20 Reviews
0 Upload
19/03/2024
Fabulous Mascara
This Neutrogena mascara is fantastic! It goes on so smoothly. It comes off just as easy. It makes my lashes look dramatically longer! I wouldn't change anything about this mascara.
Its formula, infused with vitamin E and olive oil, not only enhances my lashes but also keeps them healthy and soft. The intense Carbon Black shade adds drama to my look, and its buildable formula allows me to customize my lash style effortlessly. Plus, the precision wand ensures every lash is perfectly coated. It's a staple in my makeup routine for its performance and lash-nourishing benefits.
Laura (York Haven)
Laura (York Haven)
Lindsey (Evans)
Lindsey (Evans)
Brittany (Colorado Springs)
Brittany (Colorado Springs)
Dawn (Lake Havasu)
Dawn (Lake Havasu)
Shaunda (Honaker)
Shaunda (Honaker)
Camille (Plano)
Camille (Plano)
Liliana (Phoenix)
Liliana (Phoenix)
Hannah (West Monroe)
Hannah (West Monroe)
Nicole (Churchville)
Nicole (Churchville)
Jessica (Brighton)
Jessica (Brighton)
Erin (Wheat Ridge)
Erin (Wheat Ridge)
Maria (Weatherford)
Maria (Weatherford)
Alexandra (Chicago)
Alexandra (Chicago)
Rebecca (Silsbee)
Rebecca (Silsbee)
Anna (Philadelphia)
Anna (Philadelphia)