4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag

4.6 5 0 68 68 Fannie May’s classic Buckeye combines creamy, smooth peanut butter and luscious milk chocolate. Individually wrapped.
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Leave a review

Reviews

30/03/2023
Fantastic!
Oh my goodness, these are absolutely delicious! The chocolate has a wonderful flavor. The peanut butter in the middle is extremely smooth, and tastes great. I would absolutely recommend these, they taste better than any other candy I’ve tried in a long time.
  • Home Tested with free product
30/03/2023
just okay
Fannie May's classic Buckeyes are fairly good but they do have the overall taste of something you would expect that is highly processed. My little kiddos really enjoyed them, however, they did have a lingering taste in the mouth that I can't quite put my finger on. They have a creamy peanut butter filling that is coated in rich chocolate, creating a classic flavor combination. The individually wrapped candies seems a little wasteful to me and they were difficult to open. The peanut butter filling in Fannie May's Buckeyes is smooth, creamy, and packed with peanut flavor, making it a great complement to the chocolate coating. The filling is also slightly sweet, but not overly so, which allows the peanut butter flavor to shine through. The chocolate coating is rich and decadent, with just the right amount of sweetness to balance out the peanut butter filling. The chocolate is also smooth and velvety, which adds a satisfying texture to the overall experience.
  • Home Tested with free product
30/03/2023
So tasty!!!
I really enjoyed the buckeyes. They were fresh and the center was the best part! Would absolutely buy to have again and would also share with friends and family.
  • Home Tested with free product
30/03/2023
Delicious!
I love the Fannie May Peanut Butter Buckeyes! The chocolate and peanut butter are so smooth. It tastes like good quality chocolate. The packaging is nice, it has a ziploc on top, but to be honest they are so tasty that they won't last long.
  • Home Tested with free product
30/03/2023
Good till the last drop
I've always been a fan of Fannie Mae chocolates, so I was very excited to try the buckeyes. Overall I would have to say that they were good, a little waxy but it tasted delicious and didn't stop me from eating them all in one sitting lol.
  • Home Tested with free product
30/03/2023
Fannie May Buckeyes
I thought Fannie May Buckeyes were amazing ! Peanut butter is very creamy and the milk chocolate melts in your mouth. I did not like that they are individually wrapped but worked well in my candy dish and it probably makes you eat less when they are individually wrapped than loose because that could be very dangerous to eat the whole package !
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Delicious
Creamy and peanut buttery! Love that they’re individually wrapped. Easy to share and toss a treat in with lunch. The chocolate to peanut butter ratio is just right and the quality of the packaging and product is good.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Needs more
These are good they were fresh the chocolate was good but for me the peanut butter was way too mild could barely taste it so I would have prefer more of a peanut butter flavor.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Creamy
This product was very good and very creamy. I think it had the perfect amount of peanut butter to chocolate. I also like how there individually wrapped and was also able to ziplock it closed as well.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Excellent
The peanut butter and chocolate taste amazing together. I will definitely buy Fannie Mae buckeyes in the future. I loved getting this for free in the mail.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Great chocolates
Ye so would recommend this. This is one of the best chocolates I have tried. The penut butter was soft yet not crazy sweet. The chocolate was crispy yet melts. It was like a perfect mix of both
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Delicious!
These are so good and a luxurious treat. Reminds me of a super fancy reeces with more delicious chocolate and peanut butter. I will buy these again for myself and also as a gift for others.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Little bites of heaven
These buckeyes have been wonderful and a easy treat for me and my little ones. They are sweet and salty and already individually wrapped making them easy to take on the go. They really are a favorite around the house.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Quality chocolate
I had never tried this brand of chocolate before but heard it was good. I liked how the pieces were individually wrapped, very pretty. The chocolate was very good, and I liked how the peanut butter and chocolate tasted together. I think I would have preferred a higher chocolate to peanut butter ratio.
  • Home Tested with free product
29/03/2023
Fannie Mae Buckeyes
OMG! I love peanut butter and chocolate and these are perfect delicious little treats! It’s the perfect balance and chocolate and peanut butter. I also appreciate how it’s individually wrapped, so I can grab one and go!
  • Home Tested with free product

Testers' gallery

View More

Similar products

4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
New
Tru Fru® White & Dark Chocolate Frozen Strawberries - 8oz
4.8 5 262

4.8 from 262 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Lindor Assorted Platinum Truffles Bag
4.9 5 960

4.9 from 960 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Ghirardelli Chocolate Limited Edition Peppermint Bark Assorted Squares and Snowmen Holiday Bag
4.8 5 881

4.8 from 881 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M'S Fudge Brownie Sharing Size Chocolate Candies
4.4 5 1034

4.4 from 1,034 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
TWIX Cookies & Crème Chocolate Christmas Candy 9-oz. Bag
4.6 5 53

4.6 from 53 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M'S Fudge Brownie Christmas Chocolate Candy 9.5-oz. Bag
4.5 5 55

4.5 from 55 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M'S White Chocolate Sugar Cookie Christmas Chocolate Candy 7.44-oz. Bag
4.2 5 56

4.2 from 56 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses Filled Cane 2.56oz
4.6 5 212

4.6 from 212 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses 9 Oz.
4.6 5 345

4.6 from 345 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Kathy Kaye's Halloween Popcorn Balls
4.3 5 71

4.3 from 71 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Santa’s Super Sack 38 oz
4.6 5 25

4.6 from 25 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Dove Promises Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel
4.9 5 133

4.9 from 133 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Mars Variety Gusset
4.9 5 95

4.9 from 95 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M’s Snickers Twix & Milky Way Fun Size and Minis Christmas Candy Assortment
4.9 5 90

4.9 from 90 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Skittles Holiday Fruity Candy Jar 14 Oz
4.7 5 86

4.7 from 86 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >