This makeup eraser stick is much narrower than I expected, and because of that, it has a VERY limited function. It works PERFECTLY to remove small amounts of makeup -- but it basically is only useful to remove a tiny bit of eye makeup that wound up out of place. I'm sure it'll last me forever since I don't use it very often, and I don't know if I'd wind up buying it again.
i tried using the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser Stick with multiple types of eye makeup but it did not remove anything, it only smudged it around my face and eye.
Home Tested with free product
1
Sharlene(Lakeville)
Home Tester
2 Reviews
Sharlene(Lakeville)
Home Tester
2 Reviews
0 Upload
13/01/2020
Not the best one-use makeup tool!
This product is not what I fully expected! Does is help remove makeup mistakes - yes. But when I am fixing a makeup mistake, I don’t want the oiliness left behind that this product leaves. I felt like I needed to wipe down my skin after using the eraser stick before reapplying my makeup. So, even with this in my drawer, I still found myself reaching for a q-tip and miscellar water (which I always have on hand). I don’t see myself purchasing this product for the one use that it provides.
Home Tested with free product
1
Lisa(Elkhorn)
Home Tester
4 Reviews
Lisa(Elkhorn)
Home Tester
4 Reviews
0 Upload
13/01/2020
Neutrogena makeup remover stick
It’s nice and leaves my skin soft, but I have to use a Q-tip to remove the makeup.
Home Tested with free product
1
Michelle(Murrieta)
Home Tester
9 Reviews
Michelle(Murrieta)
Home Tester
9 Reviews
0 Upload
10/01/2020
Unfortunately I would not purchase this
I was initially looking for instructions on how to use the product. The eraser stick seems like a good idea, but can only be used for specific small mistakes. I tried to use it on my eyebrows to fix the edges and it wasn't very useful. It will take off mascara mistakes though.
Home Tested with free product
1
Lesliee(Smithfield)
Home Tester
2 Reviews
Lesliee(Smithfield)
Home Tester
2 Reviews
0 Upload
08/01/2020
Great product!
I love this stick for removing eye makeup. I wish it was a little bigger but overall I really liked it.
I’ve been looking for a product that is precise with its removing and portable. I’ve resorted to burning my eye with hand sanitizer and napkins after making a mistake in the car before. This product is permanently in my car and I plan on buying another for my work desk.
Home Tested with free product
1
Cristina(Miramar)
Home Tester
10 Reviews
Cristina(Miramar)
Home Tester
10 Reviews
0 Upload
07/01/2020
Magic in a stick!
i liked the smoothness of the stick and how well it worked to remove makeup. It felt really nice and took off everything.
I really like how smooth this product is. It doesn't feel like it's tugging on the delicate skin around the eyes to apply it or rub it off. I used to have a similar product in a department store brand, but I love having this option in a drug store price. Also, I like that it has a fairly fine point to fix the little mistakes around the eyes - especially as I love liquid eyeliner, which can be unforgiving at times.
Home Tested with free product
1
Karen(Menomonee Falls)
Home Tester Ace
21 Reviews
Karen(Menomonee Falls)
Home Tester Ace
21 Reviews
0 Upload
05/01/2020
Not a product for me
I do not feel like the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser Stick is a product that I need. It does not seem to work for me.
Home Tested with free product
1
Kerri(Jacksonville)
Home Tester
8 Reviews
Kerri(Jacksonville)
Home Tester
8 Reviews
0 Upload
03/01/2020
Smooth Like Butter on The Skin!
I liked the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser. It was convenient and small enough to carry in my purse or make up bag without taking up a lot of room. I enjoyed how smooth of an application it was. I also liked that it had Vitamin E included because that helps to keep your skin moist and not dried out. I will most likely purchase this product in the future. At this time I do not have any negatives or cons about the product.
Home Tested with free product
1
Darlene(Mcminnville)
Home Tester Ace
23 Reviews
Darlene(Mcminnville)
Home Tester Ace
23 Reviews
0 Upload
03/01/2020
Erase perfect
The Neutrogena makeup remover stick is perfect for removing little makeup mistakes perfectly and is the perfect size to take with you for all-day touch ups.
The Neutrogena makeup remover stick is a great idea, but the size of the tip is too big to be very precise. I would like it better if it was more the size of a medium point pen or if it had dual ends with a different size eraser on each end. Thank you for the opportunity to try it out.
Home Tested with free product
1
maritza(Melrose Park)
Home Tester Ace
23 Reviews
maritza(Melrose Park)
Home Tester Ace
23 Reviews
0 Upload
31/12/2019
New Concept Eye makeup remover
I love the concept of it, works on certain makeup I tried it in my liquid eyeliner and it took some work to get it to work, but I believe it works best with eye shadow
Leslie (West Sacramento)
Leslie (West Sacramento)
Melissa (Stockholm)
Melissa (Stockholm)
Sharlene (Lakeville)
Sharlene (Lakeville)
Lisa (Elkhorn)
Lisa (Elkhorn)
Michelle (Murrieta)
Michelle (Murrieta)
Lesliee (Smithfield)
Lesliee (Smithfield)
Jackie (La Habra)
Jackie (La Habra)
Anne (Cincinnati)
Anne (Cincinnati)
Cristina (Miramar)
Cristina (Miramar)
Anny (Norman)
Anny (Norman)
Karen (Menomonee Falls)
Karen (Menomonee Falls)
Kerri (Jacksonville)
Kerri (Jacksonville)
Darlene (Mcminnville)
Darlene (Mcminnville)
Christine (Newtown Square)
Christine (Newtown Square)
maritza (Melrose Park)
maritza (Melrose Park)